A content generation agency produces written and visual content in volume, and many now use AI tools somewhere in the process. This guide is for owners of local service businesses in the Twin Cities East Metro, the St. Croix Valley and western Wisconsin who are weighing one. It covers how to judge the work before you hire: what Google says about generated content, what only your business can supply, what to put in writing and how to read the results in Search Console.
It is a buyer's checklist and a ranking promise is outside its scope, because no agency can make one. For the wider question of what content agencies do and how they compare with a freelancer or an in-house hire, read our guide to content creation agencies. This post stays on volume, AI and quality control.
What a content generation agency sells
The label is not standardized. In our reading, a content generation agency sells output: a set number of articles, pages or posts each month, made by a team with a repeatable process and, increasingly, with generative AI drafting part of the work. That can be a fair arrangement when every piece carries something real. It becomes a problem when the count matters more than what each piece says.
Google's guidance on generative AI content says these tools can be useful when researching a topic and to add structure to original content. The same page says that using them to generate many pages without adding value for users may violate its spam policy on scaled content abuse. In our reading, the policy's concern is the purpose and the value to users, whichever tool is used.
What Google says about content made at scale
Scaled content abuse
Google's spam policies describe scaled content abuse as many pages generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users. They say it is typically large amounts of unoriginal content that provides little to no value to users, no matter how it's created. The listed examples include using generative AI tools to generate many pages without adding value, and creating many pages whose content makes little or no sense to a reader but contains search keywords. If you host such content, the policy says to exclude it from Search.
A pricing model built on words or articles per month rewards volume, and that deserves a question. This is our inference, which makes it a question to put to the agency and says nothing about any one firm.
Accuracy and review
Google's generative AI page says generative models don't retrieve facts but predict a likely sequence of words, so outputs may contain inaccuracies. It calls it critical to manually factcheck and review all AI-generated content for accuracy and trustworthiness before publishing, and says the review also applies to title elements, meta description elements, structured data and alternate text for images. For a service business, that is the clause that matters most. A wrong spec or a wrong code reference sits under your company's name.
Telling readers how it was made
Google's page on creating helpful, reliable, people-first content asks, for content where automation is used to substantially generate it, whether the use of automation, including AI-generation, is self-evident to visitors through disclosures or in other ways. Require the agency to say where it uses AI and where any disclosure appears, and make sure every byline leads to a real person you can call.
What only your business can supply
Our guide to outsourced content creation covers the standing facts document to give any partner. For an agency that generates content in volume, two items matter most. Technical claims such as warranty terms, product specs and code or permit references need a read by someone who does the work, and photos should come from your own jobs.
Place changes the facts, too. Minnesota's rule is narrower than it sounds. Minn. Stat. 326B.87, subdivision 2, says a licensee's license number must appear in any advertising by that licensee, including websites, and Minn. Stat. 326B.802, subdivision 5, defines "licensee" for those sections as a residential building contractor, residential remodeler, manufactured home installer or residential roofer. Wisconsin issues many trade credentials through its Department of Safety and Professional Services, whose A-Z professions list names separate credentials such as Dwelling Contractor, HVAC Contractor and Master Plumber. A business working on both sides of the St. Croix needs to tell the agency which state's rules apply to which page. This is general information and not legal advice, so confirm with the regulator or your attorney.
Questions to ask a content generation agency
The table pairs each question with what a weak and a strong answer sound like. The answers are our own reading of the Google pages above, and a strong answer is still a claim you should ask to see in writing.
Scroll to see all columns
| Question | Why it matters | Weak answer | Strong answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who edits and signs each piece? | Google's page calls for manual fact checking and review | "Our system handles quality" | A named editor who reads every piece and can be reached |
| Where does AI enter the process? | Google asks for background on how automation was used where readers would expect it | "We do not discuss our tools" | A plain account of which steps use AI and what a person checks |
| Where do the facts come from? | Generated text can contain inaccuracies | Facts pulled from the web with no source list | Your job notes, your approvals and linked primary sources |
| How is the price set? | A price per word or per article rewards volume | Only a per-word or per-article rate | A scope tied to topics, review rounds and your approvals |
| Who owns the content and the accounts? | You need to be able to move the work if you leave | The agency holds the site and the files | Everything lives in accounts in your name |
| How will results be reported? | Nobody can guarantee a ranking | A promised position or AI citation | Search Console clicks and impressions by page, plus calls and booked jobs |
What to require in writing
A contract is where a strong answer becomes a commitment. Ask for these terms.
- A named human editor and a fact check on every piece before it publishes, including titles, meta descriptions and image alt text.
- A source for each factual claim, linked to a primary page where one exists.
- A statement of how AI is used and where any disclosure appears.
- Your written approval before any technical, warranty or legal claim goes live.
- Ownership of the content, the drafts and the accounts in your name.
- A duty to rewrite or remove any page that turns out to be wrong or thin.
If an agency will not put these terms in a contract, weigh that before you sign.
Red flags
- A guaranteed ranking. Google's page on whether you need an SEO says no one can guarantee a number one ranking and tells owners to find someone else if an SEO guarantees first place.
- A promised AI citation. Google's page on AI features and your website says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode and no other special optimizations necessary. It also says indexing and serving isn't guaranteed.
- Secrecy. The same SEO page says to be careful if a company is secretive or won't clearly explain what it intends to do.
- Content on many topics in hope that some performs. Google's helpful content page lists producing lots of content on many different topics in hopes that some of it might perform well in search results among its self-check questions where a yes is a warning sign.
- No named author and no review step. Either one means the facts have no owner.
Judge the results in Search Console
Search Console's performance report help page defines clicks as how often someone clicked a link from Google to your site, and impressions as how often someone saw a link to your site on Google. It describes position as the topmost position of your link, averaged across the queries in which your property appeared. Use those definitions as the scoreboard. Save a baseline before the agency publishes and compare a matching window afterward, then look at whether the pages and queries that changed are services and towns you want. Our guide to blog post management covers reading the report page by page. For an agency, two extra checks apply.
- Separate queries that include your business name from the rest, because in our view brand searches say little about whether new content reaches people who do not know you yet.
- Check calls, forms and booked jobs in your own records, because Search Console does not show them.
Google's AI features page says indexing and serving isn't guaranteed, so in our view a fair review window runs for months.
How we handle it at McKinney Creative Ventures
McKinney Creative Ventures is based in Woodbury, Minnesota. In our brand and copy service, blog articles are long form pieces structured as real questions with direct answers, and every technical claim gets checked with the client before it publishes. We use AI the way we use any tool in the stack, for drafting and research speed, and never as the final word. We will not build a content program around high volume keyword stuffed articles. If you are planning content for your own site, contact us and we will talk through what it needs.